Many tax relief companies advertise major savings on a big tax bill from the IRS, advertising that their clients pay just “pennies on the dollar.” But taxpayers should carefully check out the details of the IRS Offer in Compromise (OIC) program to avoid being misled.

It’s easy to be confused by these ads. Settling big tax bills at a steep discount can sound tempting to struggling taxpayers. But is taking this option a real tool, or is it just a scam?

The answer is yes: The OIC being advertised by tax relief companies is a legitimate IRS program. However, qualifying requires meeting rigorous IRS standards and stringent financial formulas that advertisements conveniently ignore. This means many people apply for this tax relief when they actually don’t even remotely qualify.

Only about 15% of these OIC applications only get approved by the IRS. And the aggressive marketing of this program has prompted the IRS to repeatedly list these OIC “mills” on the agency’s annual Dirty Dozen tax scam list.

Frost Law can assist taxpayers in navigating collection alternatives, including a straightforward assessment on whether an Offer in Compromise is the right option. People can call (410) 497-5947 or schedule a confidential consultation to discuss your options. And more information about OICs can be found here on the firm’s website.

But here are some important basics about OIC’s taxpayers should first keep in mind.

Have Questions? Call us for Your consultation.

What is an Offer in Compromise?

An Offer in Compromise, or OIC, allows qualifying taxpayers to settle their tax liabilities with the IRS for less than the full amount owed. The IRS recognizes three distinct areas for these  Offers:

  1. Doubt as to Liability (DATL): There is a genuine legal dispute over whether the tax is actually owed by the taxpayers.
  2. Doubt as to Collectability (DATC): The taxpayer agrees the tax is owed, but their income and assets prove they can never pay the bill in full.
  3. Effective Tax Administration (ETA): The debt is legally correct and collectible, but paying it in full would create severe economic hardship or be fundamentally unfair to the taxpayer due to exceptional circumstances.

For most of the advertisements being marketed, these typically fall under Doubt as to Collectability.

How the IRS Evaluates Offers: Reasonable Collection Potential

When reviewing a Doubt as to Collectability submission, the IRS does not negotiate arbitrarily. Instead, it calculates the taxpayer’s Reasonable Collection Potential (RCP). The RCP sets the minimum settlement figure the IRS will accept on a tax bill. This includes two primary figures:

  • Net Realizable Equity (NRE) in Assets: This translates into the liquid cash value of assets such as real estate, vehicles, and investment accounts. Under the agency’s guidelines, the IRS generally calculates Quick Sale Value (QSV) at 80% of Fair Market Value (FMV), minus things like mortgages or auto loans. For real estate, the IRS relies on automated valuation models, county property tax assessments, and comparable sales unless the taxpayer provides a formal appraisal. Similarly, retirement funds like 401(k)s and IRAs are typically counted at their cash value minus early-withdrawal penalties and income tax withholdings.
  • Future Remaining Income: This is the taxpayer’s monthly income minus allowable standard living expenses, multiplied over a statutory collection window. This is12 months for a lump-sum offer or 24 months for periodic payments.

Here’s another common trap that limits eligibility for an OIC. If a person’s equity and disposable income show they can pay the debt over time through an Installment Agreement, the IRS will not accept a discounted Offer in Compromise settlement.

Beware of Overpromised Offers in Compromise

People actually getting an Offer in Compromise is a relatively rare thing. According to the 2025 IRS Data Book, the agency received 38,797 Offers in Compromise and accepted just 5,464—an acceptance rate of approximately 14%.

Here’s another common issue being seen. Many tax relief companies submit Offers regardless of potential outcome, even if the taxpayer clearly does not qualify.

Aggressive marketing has prompted the IRS to place Offer in Compromise ‘mills’ on its annual ‘Dirty Dozen’ list of tax scams. These firms charge thousands of dollars in upfront fees to file hopeless applications, leaving taxpayers deeper in debt while their underlying tax liability continues to accrue penalties and interest.

The IRS warns that these companies will often knowingly promote the OIC to taxpayers that will not qualify. Being aware of potential for success and seeking advice from trustworthy tax professionals can save taxpayers a great amount in unnecessary fees when considering whether an Offer is right for them.

How Do I Know if I Qualify?

There are many options for determining if a taxpayer qualifies for the Offer in Compromise. Before calculating the Reasonable Collection Potential, it’s important for applicants to verify they meet the baseline IRS filing requirements. People should make sure that:

  • All required federal tax returns are filed.
  • They have made all required estimated tax payments for the current year.
  • They are not currently in an open bankruptcy proceeding.

The IRS itself provides help in the form of its OIC pre-qualifier tool. This takes taxpayers through a series of questions regarding their income, assets, expenses, and the current status of their tax account to determine if an OIC is a possibility for resolving the debt.

While the IRS pre-qualifier tool provides a helpful preliminary estimate, consulting an experienced tax attorney or licensed Enrolled Agent can ensure deductions, asset exemptions, and statutes of limitations are properly calculated.

Frost Law encourages people to check out the details of these programs first before filing – or paying someone to file for them. And keep in mind there may be other IRS options available, including things like Installment Agreements. For people looking for help navigating collection alternatives without the aggressive marketing, Frost Law can help on Offers in Compromise and other areas. Contact Frost Law at (410) 497-5947 or schedule a confidential consultation to discuss the options.

Footnotes

go to All news articles

Is an IRS Offer in Compromise Real or a Scam? Check the Details First

Published on
November 20, 2026
Written By
download pdf
By subscribing you agree to our Privacy Policy.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Many tax relief companies advertise major savings on a big tax bill from the IRS, advertising that their clients pay just “pennies on the dollar.” But taxpayers should carefully check out the details of the IRS Offer in Compromise (OIC) program to avoid being misled.

It’s easy to be confused by these ads. Settling big tax bills at a steep discount can sound tempting to struggling taxpayers. But is taking this option a real tool, or is it just a scam?

The answer is yes: The OIC being advertised by tax relief companies is a legitimate IRS program. However, qualifying requires meeting rigorous IRS standards and stringent financial formulas that advertisements conveniently ignore. This means many people apply for this tax relief when they actually don’t even remotely qualify.

Only about 15% of these OIC applications only get approved by the IRS. And the aggressive marketing of this program has prompted the IRS to repeatedly list these OIC “mills” on the agency’s annual Dirty Dozen tax scam list.

Frost Law can assist taxpayers in navigating collection alternatives, including a straightforward assessment on whether an Offer in Compromise is the right option. People can call (410) 497-5947 or schedule a confidential consultation to discuss your options. And more information about OICs can be found here on the firm’s website.

But here are some important basics about OIC’s taxpayers should first keep in mind.

Have Questions? Call Our Team Today.

What is an Offer in Compromise?

An Offer in Compromise, or OIC, allows qualifying taxpayers to settle their tax liabilities with the IRS for less than the full amount owed. The IRS recognizes three distinct areas for these  Offers:

  1. Doubt as to Liability (DATL): There is a genuine legal dispute over whether the tax is actually owed by the taxpayers.
  2. Doubt as to Collectability (DATC): The taxpayer agrees the tax is owed, but their income and assets prove they can never pay the bill in full.
  3. Effective Tax Administration (ETA): The debt is legally correct and collectible, but paying it in full would create severe economic hardship or be fundamentally unfair to the taxpayer due to exceptional circumstances.

For most of the advertisements being marketed, these typically fall under Doubt as to Collectability.

How the IRS Evaluates Offers: Reasonable Collection Potential

When reviewing a Doubt as to Collectability submission, the IRS does not negotiate arbitrarily. Instead, it calculates the taxpayer’s Reasonable Collection Potential (RCP). The RCP sets the minimum settlement figure the IRS will accept on a tax bill. This includes two primary figures:

  • Net Realizable Equity (NRE) in Assets: This translates into the liquid cash value of assets such as real estate, vehicles, and investment accounts. Under the agency’s guidelines, the IRS generally calculates Quick Sale Value (QSV) at 80% of Fair Market Value (FMV), minus things like mortgages or auto loans. For real estate, the IRS relies on automated valuation models, county property tax assessments, and comparable sales unless the taxpayer provides a formal appraisal. Similarly, retirement funds like 401(k)s and IRAs are typically counted at their cash value minus early-withdrawal penalties and income tax withholdings.
  • Future Remaining Income: This is the taxpayer’s monthly income minus allowable standard living expenses, multiplied over a statutory collection window. This is12 months for a lump-sum offer or 24 months for periodic payments.

Here’s another common trap that limits eligibility for an OIC. If a person’s equity and disposable income show they can pay the debt over time through an Installment Agreement, the IRS will not accept a discounted Offer in Compromise settlement.

Beware of Overpromised Offers in Compromise

People actually getting an Offer in Compromise is a relatively rare thing. According to the 2025 IRS Data Book, the agency received 38,797 Offers in Compromise and accepted just 5,464—an acceptance rate of approximately 14%.

Here’s another common issue being seen. Many tax relief companies submit Offers regardless of potential outcome, even if the taxpayer clearly does not qualify.

Aggressive marketing has prompted the IRS to place Offer in Compromise ‘mills’ on its annual ‘Dirty Dozen’ list of tax scams. These firms charge thousands of dollars in upfront fees to file hopeless applications, leaving taxpayers deeper in debt while their underlying tax liability continues to accrue penalties and interest.

The IRS warns that these companies will often knowingly promote the OIC to taxpayers that will not qualify. Being aware of potential for success and seeking advice from trustworthy tax professionals can save taxpayers a great amount in unnecessary fees when considering whether an Offer is right for them.

How Do I Know if I Qualify?

There are many options for determining if a taxpayer qualifies for the Offer in Compromise. Before calculating the Reasonable Collection Potential, it’s important for applicants to verify they meet the baseline IRS filing requirements. People should make sure that:

  • All required federal tax returns are filed.
  • They have made all required estimated tax payments for the current year.
  • They are not currently in an open bankruptcy proceeding.

The IRS itself provides help in the form of its OIC pre-qualifier tool. This takes taxpayers through a series of questions regarding their income, assets, expenses, and the current status of their tax account to determine if an OIC is a possibility for resolving the debt.

While the IRS pre-qualifier tool provides a helpful preliminary estimate, consulting an experienced tax attorney or licensed Enrolled Agent can ensure deductions, asset exemptions, and statutes of limitations are properly calculated.

Frost Law encourages people to check out the details of these programs first before filing – or paying someone to file for them. And keep in mind there may be other IRS options available, including things like Installment Agreements. For people looking for help navigating collection alternatives without the aggressive marketing, Frost Law can help on Offers in Compromise and other areas. Contact Frost Law at (410) 497-5947 or schedule a confidential consultation to discuss the options.

Footnotes